1991

• Greg Ackerman 1st Team
  
• Kevin Galioto 1st Team
  
• Eli Zehner 1st Team
  
• Mark Fountain 2nd Team
  
• Tony Waldo 2nd Team
  
• Travis Erickson Honorable Mention

1992

• Travis Erickson 2nd Team
  
• Jeff Bennett Honorable Mention
  
• Jarrod Franson Honorable Mention
  
• Lance Hammack Honorable Mention
  
• Brian Hein Honorable Mention
  
• Matt Morton Honorable Mention

1993

• Jeff Bennett 1st Team
  
• Matt Morton 1st Team
  
• Brian Hein 2nd Team
  
• Hollis Erickson Honorable Mention
  
• Jarrod Franson Honorable Mention
  
• Jared Heimbigner Honorable Mention
  
• Thone Synchong Honorable Mention

1994

• Hollis Erickson 1st Team
  
• Brian Hein 1st Team
  
• Jack Anderson 2nd Team
  
• Justin Franson 2nd Team
  
• Jeff Whiting 2nd Team
  
• Jared Heimbigner Honorable Mention
  
• Alex Kerkow Honorable Mention

1995

• Justin Franson 1st Team
  
• Jared Heimbigner 1st Team
  
• Jeff Whiting 1st Team
  
• Lance Hammack 2nd Team
  
• John Greenough Honorable Mention
  
• Jeff Hadley Honorable Mention
  
• Alex Kerkow Honorable Mention

1996

• Justin Franson 1st Team
  
• Travest Story 1st Team
  
• Jeff Whiting 1st Team
  
• Mark Francis Honorable Mention
  
• Mark Leslie Honorable Mention
  
• Kevin McGuiness Honorable Mention
  
• Jeremy O'Niel Honorable Mention

1997

• Brian Hollenberg 2nd Team
  
• Kevin McGuiness Honorable Mention
  
• Erik Pederson Honorable Mention

1998

• Brandon Currie 1st Team
  
• Brian Hollenberg 1st Team
  
• Mike Rainey 2nd Team
  
• Andrew Byers Honorable Mention
  
• Erik Pederson Honorable Mention

1999

• Brandon Currie 1st Team
  
• Travis Heimbigner 2nd Team
  
• Andrew Byers Honorable Mention
  
• Josh Kessie Honorable Mention
  
• Marcus Nelson Honorable Mention
  
• Brian Wilhelm Honorable Mention

2000

• Mike Babenko 2nd Team
  
• Chris Moore Honorable Mention
  
• Jason Pele Honorable Mention
  
• Gabe Walker Honorable Mention

2001

• Jason Pele 2nd Team
  
• Mike Babenko Honorable Mention
  
• John Engelhard Honorable Mention
  
• Tanner Guy Honorable Mention
  
• Milos Hladik Honorable Mention
  
• Chris Moore Honorable Mention

2002

• Mike Babenko 1st Team
  
• Jason Pele 2nd Team
  
• Kyle Bryant Honorable Mention
  
• Jack Gunion Honorable Mention
  
• Jason Hatcher Honorable Mention

2003

• Mike Babenko 1st Team
  
• Jason Hatcher 1st Team
  
• Jason Pele 1st Team
  
• Kyle Bryant Honorable Mention
  
• Matt Hoenshell Honorable Mention
  
• Chance Ruiz Honorable Mention

2004

• Jason Hatcher 1st Team
  
• Matt Pele 1st Team
  
• Scot Bauder 2nd Team
  
• Jacob Ellig Honorable Mention
  
• Jack Gunion Honorable Mention
  
• Brenton McLaurine Honorable Mention
  
• Eric Pratt Honorable Mention

2005

• Eric Pratt 1st Team
  
• Wilbur Velasco 1st Team
  
• Brenton McLaurine 2nd Team
  
• Jeff Gilbert Honorable Mention

2006

• Brenton McLaurine 1st Team, Player of the Year
  
• Wilbur Velasco 1st Team
  
• Jeff Gilbert 1st Team
  
• Jacob Ellig 2nd Team
  
• Luis Martinez 2nd Team
  
• Dillon Braich 2nd Team
  
• Eric Richter Honorable Mention
  
• Jordan Anderson Honorable Mention

2007

• Jacob Ellig 1st Team
  
• Levi Gunion 1st Team
  
• Stephen Gilbert 1st Team
  
• Dillon Braich 2nd Team
  
• Josh Elliott 2nd Team
  
• Alex Johnson 2nd Team
  
• Curtis Moore 2nd Team